Copyright Law & New Technologies: How the Supreme Court's decision in MGM v. Grokster will affect millions of technically savvy Americans - and our modern toys.

29 Views
<<This result is different from the Napster case, in which the lower courts ruled that the service clearly was in violation of copyright law. "The other piece of good news is that the court did affirm the Sony standard. Under the Sony standard, a creator of new technology that permits copying is not liable if the technology has substantial non-infringing uses. Liability rests on the design and uses of the technology. The lower court held that Grokster and Streamcast are not liable under the Sony standard because of the design of the P2P service permitting non-infringing uses. The Supreme Court, however, concluded that the lower court had misapplied the Sony standard by focusing exclusively on the question of design and not enough on the intent of the creators of Grokster and Streamcast."

Here's where the bad news starts. "The Supreme Court basically created another way for the creator of new technology to be liable for copyright infringement," he says. "If the creator intended to induce copyright infringement, then the creator can also be found liable. To quote the court: 'One who distributes a device with the object of promoting its use to infringe copyright, as shown by clear expression or other affirmative steps taken to foster infringement, is liable for the resulting acts of infringement by third parties.'"



After today's decision, there are two potential pitfalls for creators of new technology, according to Ghosh. "The first, under Sony, is to create technology that because of its design and uses has primarily infringing uses," he says. "The second, under Grokster, is to create technology with the intent to induce infringement by third parties. The Sony standard focuses on the design of the technology, the Grokster standard on the intent of the creator. Even if the design of technology may have a lot of non-infringing uses—as Grokster and Streamcast allegedly did—the creator of new technology still can be found liable if his purpose in creating the technology was to permit copyright infringement.

In Sony, the court borrowed from the law on contributory infringement in patent law; in Grokster, the court borrowed from patent law's rules about inducement. "In its defense," Ghosh added, [the Grokster] opinion, totaling more than 50 pages in length, did show sensitivity to the arguments about technological innovation that were raised in the litigation. However, the decision also complicates copyright law by creating a new—and questionable—legal standard. Only future cases will tell how this standard will affect P2P and other technologies."

From the University at Buffalo Law School Newspaper, The Opinion
 




Featured Testimonials

Over the years I have renewed the account on and off and will continue to do so as your service has been a great help.
Frank J. Catalano


Facts

LawCrossing Fact #51: As a serious organization, LawCrossing is dedicated to finding users their dream jobs.


Location
Chicago, IL
Description
Trademark Attorney The candidate should be a junior to mid-level attorney to work in the Intellectu...
Apply now  
Location
San Diego, CA
Description
Intellectual Property Transactions Associate The candidate must be licensed to practice in Californ...
Apply now  
Location
Buffalo, NY
Description
Trademark Associate The candidate will work closely with clients to develop a strategic approach to...
Apply now  
Location
Rochester, NY
Description
Trademark Associate The candidate will work closely with clients to develop a strategic approach to...
Apply now  
Location
New York City, NY
Description
Intellectual Property Staff Attorney The candidate will be expected to work on a broad range of tra...
Apply now  
Location
Greenville, SC
Description
Patent Attorney - EE or ME Candidate will work primarily on matters related to patent prosecution a...
Apply now  
 

NOW TRENDING ON BCG ATTORNEY SEARCH

MOST POPULAR ARTICLES

Testimonial of the Week

I came back to LawCrossing to search through the listings in my new job search because I had been able to get my last 2 jobs through using the site. I love the search capacity and filters. This is a very valuable service.
  • Jennifer Guidea Bloomfield, NJ
Job of the Day

Sr. Attorney I

Washington, DC

To be part of the AMA is to be part of our Mission to promote the art and science of medicine and the betterment of publ...

Employer: American Medical Association

Job Search Tip

Some companies require all applicants to fill out an application, regardless of position. Fill it out completely, even if you have a resume.