The prosecutors, however, used Scannell's own testimony: "I thoroughly and utterly and evilly betrayed (the girl's mother's) trust," as an admission of Scannell's position of authority over the girl in question. Scannell's attorney, Joe Tamburino, argued that Scannell was never, formally or directly, given any parental responsibilities over the girl.
According to the prosecution, Scannell had abused his position of authority and when the offender is in a position of authority over the victim such conduct is fourth degree criminal sexual conduct. Scannell's sentencing would be in September.
As both the prosecution and the defense agreed, the end of the trial would help everyone concerned move forward with their lives, which in a county of only 5000 people would be a relief.
Scannell shot to national fame in 2011, after a man Scannell had successfully prosecuted for criminal sexual conduct, shot him four times in the premises of the Grand Marais courthouse.