In the competitive legal job market, one of the most common questions law students ask is: What matters more—my GPA or my experience? The answer isn’t always straightforward. Legal employers weigh a range of factors when evaluating candidates, and what’s most important can vary by firm size, practice area, and career stage.
This article breaks down how legal employers view law school GPA versus experience, and how you can position yourself as a strong candidate regardless of where your strengths lie.
Why GPA Matters—Especially Early On
In the early stages of your legal career—particularly during law school and immediately after graduation—GPA carries significant weight with employers. It often serves as a key metric in evaluating candidates during On-Campus Interviews (OCI), resume drops, and summer associate selection processes.
Here’s why GPA is especially important early on:
- Initial Screening Tool – Many law firms receive hundreds of applications and use GPA as a quick, objective way to narrow down candidates. Some firms even have strict GPA cutoffs, especially for top-tier positions.
- Academic Performance Reflects Work Ethic – A high GPA suggests you can handle complex workloads, meet deadlines, and perform under pressure—traits that align with law firm demands.
- Signal of Legal Aptitude – Strong grades in foundational courses like Civil Procedure, Contracts, and Legal Writing demonstrate that you grasp core legal concepts and can apply them effectively.
- Prestige and Competitiveness – Especially in BigLaw or elite clerkship placements, a top GPA from a reputable law school signals that you're among the best and brightest in your class.
- Access to Opportunities – Law reviews, journals, moot court, and honors programs often require high academic performance, further enhancing your resume and visibility to employers.
Bottom line: Early in your legal career, employers often rely heavily on GPA because it's one of the few available indicators of your potential. If you’re targeting top firms or highly competitive roles, strong grades can open doors, and lower ones may close them.
When Legal Experience Starts to Matter More
As you progress beyond law school and move into the early years of your legal career, practical legal experience begins to outweigh academic credentials. While a high GPA can help get your foot in the door, most employers ultimately care more about how well you can perform on the job.
Here’s when and why legal experience becomes more important:
- Lateral Hiring – For attorneys seeking to switch firms or roles, employers prioritize your track record over your transcript. They want to know what kinds of matters you've handled, what practice areas you’ve focused on, and how you’ve contributed to prior teams.
- Post-Law School Roles – Once you're a year or two out of school, employers are less interested in your GPA and more focused on your legal work product, client experience, and ability to take ownership of assignments.
- Practice Area Fit – Experience in a specific practice area (e.g., litigation, real estate, M&A, employment law) makes you more attractive to firms or companies looking for targeted skills. Even a modest GPA becomes less relevant if you bring direct experience in the employer’s niche.
- Smaller Firms and In-House Roles – Employers outside of BigLaw tend to value attorneys who can hit the ground running. Real-world experience, strong references, and client-facing skills often matter more than where you ranked in your class.
- Soft Skills and Maturity – Experience also reveals how well you manage deadlines, communicate with colleagues, and adapt to a firm’s workflow—traits that don’t show up on a transcript but are essential to success in practice.
Bottom line: As your career advances, legal employers are far more interested in what you’ve done than what you scored. Real-world experience, performance reviews, and professional reputation begin to define your value more than your law school GPA ever could. Students looking to strengthen the experience side of their résumés often choose high-value part-time jobs that build legal experience throughout law school.
How Employers Evaluate Candidates Based on Role
Different legal employers prioritize GPA and experience differently based on the role:
BigLaw (Entry-Level)
- High GPA is essential, especially from top schools.
- Law review, honors, and class rank are major pluses.
- Experience helps, but grades often lead the decision.
Small/Mid-Sized Firms
- Experience matters more, especially internships and practical skills.
- GPA is considered, but it’s not a deal-breaker.
- Culture fit and soft skills are key.
Government & Public Interest
- Relevant experience (clinics, externships) is crucial.
- Commitment to mission outweighs GPA.
- Strong writing skills are highly valued.
- Top GPA and class rank required.
- Law review and faculty recommendations carry weight.
- Excellent writing samples are a must.
In-House Roles
- Experience and business understanding matter most.
- GPA rarely matters after a few years in practice.
- Communication and risk management skills are key.
Legal Tech & Consulting
- Innovation and adaptability trump GPA.
- Project experience and leadership are more important.
- Legal background is a bonus, not a requirement.
Tip: Tailor your strengths (GPA or experience) to match what each role values most.
How to Compensate for a Low GPA
If your law school GPA isn’t as strong as you'd like, you're not alone—and it doesn't have to define your legal career. Many successful attorneys had modest grades but made up for it with strategic decisions, real-world experience, and strong professional branding. Here’s how you can stand out even with a lower GPA: For law students weighing grades versus hands-on experience, these career‑launch strategies for law students provide practical guidance.
1. Gain Relevant Legal Experience
Hands-on experience is one of the best ways to shift attention away from grades.- Pursue internships, externships, or part-time clerkships during law school.
- Work in practice areas you’re targeting, even in unpaid roles, to show commitment and capability.
- Highlight real work product—such as research memos or filings—that demonstrate your skills.
2. Build a Niche Practice Area
Specializing in a less saturated or in-demand area of law can make you more marketable.- Consider areas like compliance, data privacy, healthcare, environmental law, or tax law.
- Gaining certifications (e.g., CIPP/US for privacy law or CPA for tax) can further boost your profile.
3. Network Strategically
Personal connections can open doors that grades cannot.- Attend legal networking events, bar association meetings, and webinars.
- Use LinkedIn and alumni networks to set up informational interviews.
- Seek referrals or recommendations from attorneys you've worked with.
4. Improve Your Resume and Cover Letter
Tailor every job application to show that you’re more than your transcript.- Focus on skills, accomplishments, and results in your experience.
- Use your cover letter to explain your passion, growth, and why you're a strong fit for the firm.
- Highlight traits like reliability, leadership, and client service.
5. Create a Strong Writing Sample or Portfolio
A standout writing sample can prove your legal reasoning and writing ability.- Choose a piece that showcases clarity, structure, and legal insight.
- If possible, use something from real work experience (with client info redacted).
6. Develop a Personal Brand
Showcase your expertise outside the classroom.- Start a legal blog, write LinkedIn posts, or publish articles in legal journals.
- Get involved in law school clubs, moot court, or competitions to demonstrate initiative.
7. Be Honest—But Positive—About Your GPA
If it comes up, don’t get defensive. Instead, explain how you’ve grown and what you’ve done to gain practical skills.Bottom line: A low GPA isn't the end of the road—it’s just one piece of your story. Focus on building real-world experience, making meaningful connections, and demonstrating your value through tangible actions, not just academic achievements. Many employers will overlook grades if you demonstrate you're the right person for the job. To complement this analysis, see Navigating Legal Waters: Essential Principles for Law Students for practical tips on excelling in both areas.
How to Maximize Your Strengths
Whether your strength is GPA, experience, or both, leverage it effectively:
- Strong GPA? Emphasize academic honors, coursework, and intellectual rigor.
- Strong Experience? Highlight practical skills, real-world results, and professional references.
- Balanced Profile? Showcase both with tailored resumes, cover letters, and interviews.
Tip: Tailor your resume and interview responses to match what each specific employer values most.
| See Related Articles |
Final Thoughts
So, what matters more—GPA or experience? The real answer: it depends on the employer, the role, and where you are in your legal career. For law students, a high GPA plays a crucial role early on, especially when pursuing Big Law and clerkships. However, as your career evolves, experience, reputation, and practical skills become the primary factors driving hiring decisions.
Focus on strengthening whichever side of your profile needs more support—and remember, many paths lead to legal success.
