Your résumé is your first impression—and in the legal profession, that first impression is everything. Law firms receive hundreds of applications for each opening, and often spend just seconds scanning a résumé before making a decision. If yours contains red flags—whether big or small—it can send your application straight to the rejection pile.
Understanding what hiring partners, legal recruiters, and HR professionals consider warning signs is essential if you want to stand out in a competitive market. This article breaks down the attorney résumé red flags that most commonly cost candidates interviews—and how to avoid them.
Unexplained Employment Gaps
One of the fastest ways to raise concerns with law firm hiring managers is to have noticeable gaps in your employment history without any explanation. In the legal industry—where consistency, reliability, and performance are key—employers want to understand why you weren’t working, what you did during that time, and whether it reflects on your long-term commitment or readiness to rejoin the workforce.
While career gaps are more common than ever (especially post-pandemic), failing to address them directly can make you appear evasive, unprepared, or worse—unreliable.
Why Employment Gaps Raise Red Flags
Hiring partners and recruiters often interpret unexplained gaps as:
- A possible termination or underperformance issue
- Evidence of instability or lack of career direction
- Time spent struggling to find work or adjust to a prior job loss
- A signal that you may leave again or struggle to reintegrate
Common and Acceptable Reasons for Gaps
Many gaps are completely legitimate and easily understood—if they are explained properly. These include:
- Parental leave or caregiving responsibilities
- Health-related leave (personal or family)
- Pursuing an advanced degree or certification
- Travel, relocation, or visa issues
- Bar exam study or re-licensing in a new jurisdiction
- Economic downturns or firm layoffs
How to Address Employment Gaps on Your Resume
✅ Include a One-Line ClarifierIn your résumé, consider inserting a brief, direct explanation in the timeline. For example:
- Jan 2022 – Dec 2022: Parental Leave
- July 2021 – March 2022: Transition Period – Relocated and Studied for the California Bar Exam
- 2019 – 2020: Career Break – Family Caregiving (continued CLE and legal writing projects)
✅ Use the Cover Letter to Add Context
If needed, use your cover letter to briefly explain the gap and, more importantly, highlight how you’re ready and qualified for the current opportunity. Maintain a positive, forward-looking, and confident tone.
✅ Show Continued Engagement
Mention any part-time consulting, CLE courses, bar association involvement, writing, or pro bono work you did during your time off. This reinforces your commitment to the profession.
Gaps on a résumé are not deal-breakers, but unexplained gaps often are. Hiring managers aren’t looking for perfection. They’re looking for honesty, professionalism, and clarity. A simple explanation goes a long way in removing doubt and moving your candidacy forward. After reviewing these red flags, consult our Legal Resume Refresh: 2025 Best Practices That Land Interviews article to learn how to refresh your résumé and avoid these pitfalls entirely.
Too Many Short-Term Jobs
A résumé that shows multiple roles lasting less than one to two years can signal instability, lack of commitment, or poor fit—all red flags for law firms investing in long-term talent. While a single short stint is understandable, a pattern raises concerns about your ability to stay the course or work effectively within a team.
How to address it:
- Provide context in your résumé or cover letter (e.g., firm mergers, relocations, contract roles).
- Emphasize growth, not movement—show how each transition advanced your skills or career focus.
- Be prepared to explain your decisions clearly and confidently in interviews.
Vague or Generic Job Descriptions
One of the most common mistakes attorneys make on their résumés is using vague, generic language that fails to convey the value of their work. Phrases like “Drafted legal documents,” “Attended hearings,” or “Provided legal advice” are so broad that they tell hiring managers almost nothing about your skill level, specialization, or accomplishments.
In a competitive legal market, your résumé must differentiate you from hundreds of other qualified candidates—and that means being specific, results-oriented, and tailored to your target role.
Why Generic Descriptions Hurt You
When your job descriptions are too broad or templated:
- You look indistinguishable from other candidates.
- It’s unclear what type of law you practice.
- Recruiters don’t know what industries or client types you serve.
- You miss the chance to show how you add value, not just perform tasks.
Generic job descriptions are a missed opportunity. Your résumé should act like a highlight reel, showcasing your unique strengths, industry knowledge, and impact. Make every bullet count.
Lack of Practice Area Focus
One of the biggest reasons attorney résumés get overlooked is that they don’t clearly convey what kind of lawyer you are. If a hiring partner can’t immediately tell whether you're a litigator, a corporate associate, or an employment counsel, they’ll move on to someone whose specialty is obvious.
Your résumé should position you as a clear fit for a specific type of legal role. Law firms don’t want generalists—they want attorneys who bring defined expertise in practice areas they actively need.
Why Practice Area Clarity Matters
In lateral hiring, law firms typically seek attorneys to fill a specific gap on their team. That means:
- If the firm needs an M&A associate, your résumé should scream M&A.
- If the firm needs a securities litigator, it should highlight that experience first.
- If the firm is growing its data privacy team, you should emphasize regulatory compliance, privacy frameworks, and related clients.
Signs of an Unfocused Resume
- Practice areas scattered across unrelated industries
- Equal emphasis on litigation and corporate work
- Vague terms like “handled various legal matters”
- Listing every task you’ve ever done, regardless of relevance
A résumé without a clear focus on a specific practice area looks scattered, and scattered isn’t strategic. If you want to secure interviews, your résumé must tell a cohesive and confident story about the type of lawyer you are and the value you bring.
Typos, Formatting Errors, or Inconsistencies
In the legal profession, attention to detail isn’t optional—it’s expected. Your résumé is often the first (and sometimes only) document a hiring partner will review before deciding whether to interview you. Even one typo or formatting issue can seriously damage your credibility, signaling that you may not have the precision and professionalism required to handle client matters or draft complex legal documents.
Law firms view your résumé as a reflection of your work product. If it looks rushed, inconsistent, or sloppy, they’ll assume the same about your legal work—and quickly move on to a candidate who appears more polished and reliable.
Why Minor Mistakes Make a Major Impact
Hiring managers and legal recruiters routinely reject résumés with:
- Spelling or grammar errors
- Inconsistent formatting (e.g., date alignment, bullet point styles, font usage)
- Mismatched verb tenses or punctuation
- Conflicting information (e.g., overlapping job dates or bar admission years)
Common Mistakes Attorneys Make
- Using multiple fonts or font sizes throughout the document
- Inconsistent formatting of dates (e.g., “March 2022 – Present” vs. “3/22 – Present”)
- Shifting bullet styles (dots, dashes, or inconsistent indentation)
- Typos in firm names, client names, or case citations
- Capitalization errors or inconsistent spacing between sections
Typos and formatting issues are some of the easiest résumé mistakes to fix—yet they’re also among the most costly. In a profession that values precision, your résumé should demonstrate that you can be trusted with high-stakes legal work. Take the time to get it right.
Including Irrelevant or Outdated Information
Overloading your résumé with old jobs, outdated software skills, or unrelated experiences can dilute your strengths and make it harder for hiring managers to see your true value. Law firms want to quickly understand what you bring to the table today, not what you did 15 years ago in a different field.
How to fix it:
- Focus on the most recent 10–15 years of relevant legal experience.
- Remove pre-law jobs unless they directly relate to your practice (e.g., finance, compliance).
- Omit outdated technologies, certifications, or high school achievements.
No Evidence of Career Progression
A strong résumé should tell the story of professional growth. If your experience indicates that you've been in the same role, performing the same tasks at the same level for several years—with no indication of advancement—it can raise concerns about your ambition, performance, or adaptability.
Law firms want attorneys who are not only consistent performers but also driven to take on more responsibility, expand their skills, and move forward. A résumé that lacks any sign of development can suggest you’ve stagnated—or worse, that you haven’t earned trust or opportunity in past roles
Why Career Progression Matters
Hiring managers often use your résumé to assess:
- Whether you’ve earned increased responsibility over time
- If you've taken initiative to lead or mentor
- How your work has evolved in complexity or scope
- Whether you’ve become more client-facing or strategic
Résumés that show no forward momentum leave hiring teams wondering, “Is this person just coasting?” To secure interviews, demonstrate that you’re not only capable but also constantly growing.
Missing Law School Details or Bar Admission
Believe it or not, one of the most common—and most damaging—résumé mistakes attorneys make is omitting basic educational and licensure information. If your résumé doesn’t clearly list your law school, graduation year, and bar admission(s), many hiring partners or recruiters will pass on your application immediately, assuming you’re either careless or unqualified.
This information may seem obvious or easy to verify, but in a competitive legal market, your résumé must answer essential questions quickly and completely. Otherwise, firms will simply move on to candidates whose qualifications are clearly documented.
Why This Is a Red Flag
Hiring managers and legal recruiters often assume that missing academic or bar details means:
- You haven’t passed the bar (or are only provisionally admitted)
- You didn’t attend a reputable or ABA-accredited law school
- You’re trying to conceal something (e.g., poor academic performance or disciplinary issues)
- You’re inattentive to detail—a major red flag in the legal field
What to Include on Your Resume
✅ Law School Information
- Full name of your law school
- Graduation year
- Academic honors (e.g., cum laude, Law Review, Moot Court)
- Relevant coursework (optional, if targeting a specialized role or you’re a recent graduate)
Example:
University of Michigan Law School, J.D., 2018 – cum laude, Michigan Law Review (Associate Editor)
✅ Bar Admission(s)
- State(s) where you are admitted
- Year of admission (optional, but helpful)
- Any pending or inactive statuses, if relevant
- Include federal court admissions if applicable
Example:
Admitted to the State Bar of California (2019)
Admitted to U.S. District Court, Central District of California
If you’re not yet admitted, indicate your status:
Bar Admission Pending – New York, July 2024
Where to Place This Information
- Education section for law school details
- Separate section labeled “Bar Admissions” near the bottom of your résumé, or just below Education if early-career
- Certifications section if you’re also licensed in other jurisdictions or hold special credentials
| See Related Articles |
Final Thought: Your Resume Is a Strategic Document—Not a Biography
Your résumé isn’t a laundry list of everything you’ve done. It’s a strategic marketing tool designed to show law firms exactly why they should interview you—and how you’ll add value from day one. By identifying and removing red flags, you increase your chances of landing interviews, getting callbacks, and advancing your legal career.
