The lateral hiring market is more competitive than ever, and while law firms are constantly looking to add new talent, they’re not just filling seats. Behind every interview, résumé review, and lateral partner discussion, law firms are asking: “Will this person make our firm stronger?”
Whether you’re a junior associate or a partner with a book of business, understanding what law firms are really looking for when hiring lateral attorneys is the key to positioning yourself for success—and avoiding costly mistakes in your job search.
This article breaks down the core qualities firms prioritize, common misconceptions, and the often-unspoken red flags that can derail your candidacy.
1. A Strong and Transferable Skill Set
The first—and often most critical—criterion law firms evaluate when hiring a lateral attorney is whether you bring a strong, transferable skill set that meets an immediate or strategic need within the firm. While pedigree, firm background, and bar admissions matter, they’re secondary to your ability to contribute right away in areas where the firm is actively busy or growing.This is especially important because lateral hiring decisions are typically driven by client demand. Firms aren't just adding headcount—they're hiring attorneys who can step in and add value with minimal training or ramp-up time.
What Makes a Skill Set "Transferable"?
A transferable skill set means you can move seamlessly into a new environment and immediately handle client matters that align with the hiring firm’s existing workload.This typically includes:
- Substantive experience in a relevant practice area (e.g., M&A, commercial litigation, patent prosecution, fund formation, employment counseling)
- Hands-on responsibility managing cases or deals—not just shadowing or supporting partners
- Familiarity with industry-specific clients or regulatory frameworks
- The ability to work independently and under pressure
What Law Firms Look for on Your Resume
To assess whether your skills are transferable, law firms will scrutinize:- Representative matters: Are they similar to the work the firm does?
- Client types: Have you worked with institutions, startups, Fortune 500s, or individuals that align with their client base?
- Deal/case complexity: Can you handle high-stakes work?
- Level of responsibility: Were you just a supporting player, or did you take ownership of key components?
They’re looking for attorneys who can step in and bill, not ones who need to be trained from the ground up. No matter how impressive your credentials are, firms will pass on you if your skills don’t clearly translate to their current client work. You must be able to walk in, start billing, and make the partners’ lives easier. To align your profile with firm expectations, review our Lateral Attorney Moves: Strategic Guide to Switching Firms in 2026 for practical tips on presenting your experience effectively.
2. Cultural Compatibility and Soft Skills
While technical skills and impressive credentials may get you in the door, cultural compatibility and soft skills often determine whether you’ll get the offer. Law firms are increasingly prioritizing attorneys who not only perform well on paper but also integrate smoothly into the firm’s culture, collaborate effectively with others, and build strong internal and client relationships.
In a profession known for high performance and high pressure, emotional intelligence, communication style, and interpersonal dynamics can significantly impact whether a lateral hire succeeds or fails.
Why Culture Fit Matters to Law Firms
Every firm has its own culture—whether it's highly entrepreneurial, traditional and hierarchical, socially driven, or all-business. When firms hire lateral attorneys, they're not just filling a skills gap; they're adding someone to their team dynamic and reputation.
A lateral who doesn’t fit the firm’s culture can:
- Undermine morale
- Clash with leadership or peers
- Frustrate clients with tone or attitude
- Leave early, wasting time and resources on recruitment and onboarding
The Soft Skills Firms Want in Lateral Attorneys
- Communication Skills
- Can you explain complex legal concepts in clear, client-friendly terms?
- Do you write clearly and speak confidently?
- Can you manage difficult conversations with clients or colleagues?
- Collaboration and Team Orientation
- Are you easy to work with?
- Do you share credit, respect hierarchy, and support junior and senior colleagues?
- Can you integrate with cross-functional or multi-office teams?
- Emotional Intelligence
- Are you aware of how your behavior impacts others?
- Do you read a room, show empathy, and adapt your style accordingly?
- Adaptability
- Can you handle change, ambiguity, and firm-specific processes without resistance?
- Are you coachable and open to feedback?
- Client-Facing Presence
- Are you professional, responsive, and easy to trust?
- Do you naturally build rapport and effectively represent the firm?
How Firms Evaluate Culture Fit During the Hiring Process
- Behavioral interviews: Firms will ask situational questions like “Describe a time you had to manage conflict on a team” or “How do you handle client pushback?”
- Team interviews: You may meet with associates, junior partners, or staff to gauge how well you’d collaborate at different levels.
- Off-script conversations: Informal chats can reveal attitude, humility, or red flags that structured interviews don’t.
- Your questions: What you ask them also signals your values, priorities, and whether you’ve researched the firm culture.
3. A Clear and Legitimate Reason for Leaving
When law firms consider hiring a lateral attorney, one of the first—and most scrutinized—questions they ask is:
“Why is this person leaving their current firm?”
Your answer to this question matters immensely. It gives hiring partners insight into your motivations, stability, judgment, and long-term potential. Even the most technically skilled attorney can raise concerns if their reason for leaving feels vague, reactive, or self-serving.
To be competitive in the lateral hiring process, you must present a clear, professional, and forward-looking explanation for your move—one that makes sense within the context of your résumé and career narrative.
Lateral hiring is time-consuming and costly. Firms want to avoid:
- Candidates who jump firms frequently for minor reasons
- Attorneys who might be difficult to manage or satisfy
- Red flags around interpersonal conflict or poor performance
- People who will quickly leave again, damaging morale and wasting resources
Good Reasons for Leaving That Resonate with Firms
- Lack of practice area alignment: You want to specialize in an area your current firm doesn’t support.
- Geographic relocation: You’re moving to be closer to family or due to a spouse’s job.
- Desire for a better platform: You’re looking for stronger support, infrastructure, or brand for your growing client base.
- Limited advancement opportunities: You’ve hit a ceiling where you are, and your path to partnership or promotion is blocked.
- Client conflicts: Your client base is restricted by firm conflicts that limit your growth.
- Cultural misalignment: You’re seeking a more collaborative, entrepreneurial, or flexible environment, and can articulate that clearly and professionally.
Weak or Risky Reasons to Avoid (or Reframe)
- Badmouthing the current firm or colleagues
- “I just need a change” (too vague)
- “I’m burned out” (raises sustainability concerns)
- “The hours are too much” (implies you might not thrive in similar settings)
- “I didn’t get along with a partner” (signals potential interpersonal issues)
4. Business Potential (Yes, Even for Associates)
Law firms are businesses, and while legal skill and reliability are essential, what truly drives success is the ability to attract, grow, and retain client relationships. This is why, even at the associate level, firms are evaluating your business potential, not just your ability to bill hours.
If you’re a mid-level or senior associate thinking, “I’m not expected to bring in clients yet,” think again. While you may not have your book of business, law firms want to see early signs of entrepreneurial thinking, industry engagement, and client-facing capability.
Why Firms Care About Business Potential—Even Early On
Today’s law firms are looking for future rainmakers. Lateral hiring is not just about filling immediate needs—it’s about investing in people who will generate revenue long-term. Partners want to know:- Can this associate eventually help expand our client base?
- Are they developing the right instincts and network now?
- Will they grow into someone we can trust with client relationships?
5. A Clean Reputation (On and Offline)
In today’s interconnected legal market, your reputation travels faster than your résumé. When law firms evaluate lateral candidates, they don’t just rely on transcripts, writing samples, or interviews—they also dig into your professional reputation, both in the legal community and online.
A stellar résumé can be quickly undermined by rumors of unreliability, toxic behavior, or even an unprofessional digital footprint. That’s why maintaining a clean, credible, and consistent reputation is essential to getting hired—and staying competitive.
Why Reputation Matters to Law Firms
Lateral hiring is an investment. Before bringing someone into the fold, firms want to know:- Will this person reflect well on our brand?
- Will clients and colleagues enjoy working with them?
- Are there any ethical, behavioral, or performance concerns?
Hiring committees often consult:
- Former colleagues and mentors
- Recruiters who’ve interacted with the candidate before
- Opposing counsel or judges (for litigators)
- Online activity on LinkedIn, Glassdoor, or social media
6. Stability and Commitment
In the lateral hiring process, law firms aren't just looking for talent—they’re looking for stability. A candidate who appears flighty, uncertain, or overly opportunistic raises red flags, regardless of their skill level. Law firms want to see that you have a track record of commitment, professional maturity, and staying power.
Why? Because making a lateral hire is a significant investment. Firms allocate time, money, and resources to onboard new attorneys. If you’re likely to leave in a year or two—or have a pattern of short stints—it raises the risk that they’ll be back in the market to fill your role again soon.
Why Stability Matters in Lateral Hiring
Law firms value lateral attorneys who demonstrate:- Career focus and follow-through
- Clear, well-reasoned decisions when moving between jobs
- A desire to grow and contribute long-term within the firm
- Predictability and low risk of turnover—a major issue for firm morale and profitability
- Lack of loyalty or resilience
- Poor decision-making
- Challenges working within teams or firm structures
- A transactional approach to career moves
What Firms Are Evaluating in Your Career History
Hiring partners will often look at your résumé and ask:
- How long have you stayed at previous firms?
- Is there a pattern of leaving every 1–2 years?
- Do the reasons for past moves make sense?
- Does this candidate seem like someone who will stay and grow here?
Law firms are seeking lateral hires who won’t just plug a short-term gap, but who will build, grow, and stay. Even if you're still figuring out your long-term path, showing thoughtful planning and a commitment to making your next move count goes a long way.
7. Practice Area Alignment
One of the most important—but often overlooked—factors in lateral attorney hiring is the alignment of practice areas. Law firms don’t just want strong attorneys—they want the right attorneys for their current business strategy, client demand, and team composition. No matter how credentialed or experienced you are, if your practice doesn’t align with what the firm needs right now, you’re not a good fit.
This is why even highly qualified candidates get passed over—not because they aren’t good lawyers, but because their skills and focus simply don’t match the firm’s priorities.
Why Practice Area Fit Is Critical
Law firms operate like businesses. Their hiring decisions are based on:- Client demand in specific practice areas
- Strategic growth goals (e.g., expanding a regulatory practice or building an IP litigation team)
- The bandwidth of existing partners and associates
- Profitability forecasts for different service lines
8. Portable Book of Business (For Partners and Senior Counsel)
If you’re a partner or senior counsel pursuing a lateral move, the single most important factor law firms will evaluate is your portable book of business. No matter how respected you are, how impressive your resume may be, or how many years you've practiced, your ability to bring clients with you is the strongest predictor of whether you’ll receive an offer, and on what terms.
In today’s law firm economy, lateral partner hiring is primarily driven by revenue generation and client development. Firms want to know: Can you bring in work, bill consistently, and grow your practice within their platform?
What Is a Portable Book of Business?
A portable book of business refers to the clients and revenue streams you can realistically bring with you when you switch firms. This includes:- Clients who are loyal to you personally, not just the brand of your current firm
- Clients with no conflicts at the new firm
- Clients who will authorize you to continue work after your move
- Clients who generate repeatable, sustainable revenue, not one-off projects
Why Law Firms Prioritize a Portable Book
Hiring a lateral partner without a portable book is risky unless they fill a very specific, high-demand niche. Most firms want partners who:
- Will immediately contribute to firm profitability
- Can cover their base compensation through origination credit
- Bring new clients or expanded work from existing industries
- Reduce dependence on a few rainmakers or institutional clients
- Open doors to cross-selling and internal referrals
What Numbers Do Firms Expect?
While expectations vary by market and firm size, here are general benchmarks:
| Role | Minimum Portable Book (Typical) |
|---|---|
| Senior Counsel | $250K–$500K |
| Non-Equity Partner | $500K–$750K |
| Equity Partner | $1M+ |
In major markets like New York, D.C., or Los Angeles, expectations may be significantly higher, especially at Am Law 100 firms. Some firms will make exceptions—but usually only if your practice is rare or your addition strengthens a partner’s existing book. For insights on how to align your next career step with what firms truly value, the Lateral Attorney Moves: Strategic Guide to Switching Firms in 2026 breaks down strategies for evaluating offers and cultural fit.
For senior lawyers, your portable book is your calling card. It reflects your ability to generate revenue, build trust, and grow relationships. Without it, your options may be limited. With it, you have leverage, mobility, and a seat at the table.
In the eyes of most firms, clients don’t belong to institutions—they belong to relationships. And relationships belong to rainmakers.
| See Related Articles |
Prepare, Position, and Play the Long Game
Getting hired as a lateral attorney isn’t just about being a good lawyer—it’s about being the right fit at the right time with the right story. By understanding what law firms truly care about, you can craft a smarter, more strategic application and increase your chances of making a meaningful career move.
Be clear. Be credible. Be client-ready. That’s what gets you hired.
