As law school graduation approaches, one of the most significant decisions many students face is whether to begin their legal career with a judicial clerkship or a law firm associate position. Both paths offer valuable experience, strong career development, and long-term professional benefits—but they’re not interchangeable.
Choosing the right first step after law school requires more than following prestige or a paycheck. It depends on your career goals, practice interests, financial situation, and long-term vision. This article breaks down the pros and cons of starting in a clerkship vs. a law firm and offers practical guidance to help you decide which path is the best fit for you.
Why This Decision Matters
The first step you take after law school can significantly influence the direction—and momentum—of your legal career. Whether you choose to begin with a judicial clerkship or a law firm associate position, you’re not just accepting a job. You’re shaping your skill set, defining your professional identity, and sending a signal to future employers about your interests and ambitions.
This decision matters because it impacts multiple aspects of your early legal development:
- Skill Building: A judicial clerkship immerses you in legal analysis, opinion writing, and close mentorship from a judge. A law firm position plunges you into the fast-paced world of client work, real deadlines, and business-driven legal practice. Each path builds a distinct set of skills—some transferable, some more practice-specific.
- Career Trajectory: Clerkships can serve as launchpads into litigation, public interest, academia, or government roles, while law firms offer a direct route to private sector advancement, in-house roles, or specialization in corporate, tax, or regulatory practice. Where you begin can influence where you’re positioned—and what opportunities open to you later.
- Reputation and Resume Impact: A federal or high-level state clerkship carries significant weight on a resume, often unlocking doors to competitive litigation jobs and post-clerkship bonuses. A law firm role, especially in Big Law, offers immediate prestige, high earnings, and a structured pathway to partnership or lateral moves.
- Financial Considerations: Student loan debt, cost of living, and long-term earning potential all play a role. Law firm salaries can provide immediate financial relief, while clerkships often pay less but offer bonuses and delayed value through enhanced career prospects.
- Personal and Professional Clarity: A clerkship can offer time to reflect, observe, and refine your legal interests before diving into practice. A law firm position immerses you in the realities of client service and firm life from the very beginning. Depending on your readiness and career vision, one path may provide the clarity and momentum you need most.
Option 1: Start with a Judicial Clerkship
But a clerkship is more than an academic exercise—it’s a strategic move with lasting professional benefits.
What Is a Judicial Clerkship?
A judicial clerkship is typically a one- or two-year position in which a recent law graduate works directly with a judge in a federal, state, or appellate court. As a clerk, your responsibilities might include:- Researching complex legal issues
- Drafting bench memos, opinions, and orders
- Observing hearings and trials
- Managing case files and procedural matters
- Providing the judge with analytical support
Key Advantages of Starting with a Clerkship
1. Mentorship and TrainingYou’ll receive one-on-one guidance from a judge who often serves as both mentor and reference for the rest of your career. You also gain access to a broader network of former clerks, fellow clerks, and court personnel.
2. Legal Writing Mastery
Clerks spend most of their time researching and drafting. Your writing will improve dramatically, and you'll develop a skill set that firms, agencies, and public interest organizations deeply value.
3. Career Prestige and Flexibility
- Litigation roles at top law firms
- Government and public interest positions
- Judicial and academic careers
- Higher-level clerkships or fellowships
4. Hiring and Compensation Advantages
Many law firms offer clerkship bonuses (typically ranging from $50,000 to $100,000+) and seniority credit, meaning you may start at a higher salary tier when you join after clerking.
5. Time to Reflect
Unlike the immediate pace of law firm life, a clerkship allows you to observe lawyers in action, explore different legal paths, and refine your career goals before committing to a practice area or employer.
Considerations and Trade-Offs
- Lower Initial Salary: Clerkships typically pay significantly less than associate roles at law firms. While post-clerkship bonuses can offset this, it may be a challenge if you’re managing heavy student debt or cost-of-living pressures.
- Temporary Nature: Most clerkships last one or two years. You’ll need to prepare for another job search soon after starting your career.
- Limited Client Exposure: Clerks operate in a research and writing environment, not a client-service setting. You may not gain much exposure to business development, client interaction, or hands-on case work.
- Competitive Application Process: Clerkships, particularly those at the federal level, are extremely competitive. High grades, Law Review, and strong faculty recommendations are often essential.
Best Candidates for Clerkships
- Students interested in litigation, appellate law, criminal justice, or public interest
- Those who want to sharpen their legal writing and build academic credentials
- Graduates aiming for judicial, government, or academic careers
- Law students seeking time to explore before committing to a specific legal path
Starting your legal career with a judicial clerkship is an investment in your long-term potential. While the short-term paycheck may be smaller, the experience can dramatically increase your value, insight, and marketability across nearly every sector of the legal profession. If your strengths lie in research and writing—and your ambitions include litigation, public service, or future judicial work—a clerkship may be the most strategic first step you can take.
Option 2: Start with a Law Firm Associate Position
For many graduating law students—particularly those pursuing a career in the private sector—starting as a law firm associate offers immediate financial security, practical experience, and a structured path to long-term success. Whether you’re joining a large corporate firm, a boutique litigation shop, or a regional practice, the law firm environment provides hands-on training, access to real-world clients, and a crash course in the business of law.
While clerkships offer intellectual rigor, law firms deliver professional momentum. If you’re eager to dive into substantive legal work and build your network from day one, this may be your ideal launchpad.
What Is a Law Firm Associate's Role?
A law firm associate is an entry-level attorney who works under the supervision of partners and senior attorneys. Associates handle a range of legal tasks, including:- Conducting legal research and writing memos
- Drafting contracts, briefs, and pleadings
- Managing case files and due diligence
- Attending depositions, closings, and hearings
- Interacting with clients and opposing counsel
Best Candidates for Law Firm Roles
- Students aiming for private sector careers or in-house counsel positions
- Graduates with transactional interests (e.g., M&A, finance, securities)
- Students seeking early financial stability
- Individuals who thrive in fast-paced, client-facing environments
- Graduates are confident in their practice area preferences and ready to build expertise
A law firm associate position offers unmatched opportunities to learn on the job, earn a strong income, and launch a successful legal career in the private sector. It’s ideal for graduates ready to hit the ground running, develop practical skills, and build lasting professional relationships. If your goals include partnership, in-house counsel roles, or early specialization in a high-demand practice area, starting at a law firm may be your smartest first move. If you’re weighing the long-term implications of each path, our article on Judicial Clerkship Career Impact provides detailed guidance.
| Factor | Judicial Clerkship | Law Firm Position |
|---|---|---|
| Salary | Lower (public sector) | High (especially BigLaw) |
| Skill Focus | Research, writing, legal reasoning | Practical lawyering, client service |
| Mentorship | Close guidance from a judge | Structured programs, firm partners |
| Duration | 1–2 years (temporary) | Ongoing, long-term |
| Prestige | Highly regarded, especially in litigation | Varies by firm size and practice group |
| Exit Opportunities | Boosts clerkship + litigation, + public sector | Strong for the private sector + in-house |
| Best Fit For | Litigators, clerks, and public interest attorneys | Corporate attorneys, private practice paths |
| See Related Articles |
Final Takeaway: Choose Based on Your Long-Term Goals
There’s no “right” answer—just a right answer for you. If you want to sharpen your analytical skills, build credibility in court, or pursue litigation, a judicial clerkship is an excellent first step. If you want to gain immediate practice experience, earn a high salary, or build a foundation in private law, a law firm associate position may be the better fit.
Some attorneys do both: starting with a clerkship and then moving into a firm with a signing bonus and greater clarity about their path. Others start in a firm, then apply for clerkships later.
Whichever you choose, make your decision deliberately, not based on prestige alone, but on what will best serve your skills, interests, financial needs, and career vision.
