Search using our robust engine. Get the recommendations you need to get ahead.
Browse through our expansive list of legal practice areas.
Work where you are or where you would like to be. Find where you will work with LawCrossing.
Use our marketplace to feature your opportunity
Start your search today
Set up your account and manage your company profile on LawCrossing
Look through and compare company profiles
Learn from the legal expert, Harrison Barnes
Discover salaries and the scope of your next job
LawCrossing Works Read Testimonials and Share your Story
Suffering Lies in Your Perception of the Fact and Not the Fact Itself
published September 07, 2015
Like patent protection, copyright protection in the U.S. is conferred by federal law, based on a specific provision of the Constitution. Federal copyright protection applies to literary, musical and dramatic works, pictorial, sculptural and audiovisual works, and other kinds of works of authorship, including computer program expression. Copyright protection for works created today begins when the work is first "fixed in a tangible medium of expression," i.e., written down or otherwise recorded. It lasts for the life of the author plus fifty years.
The owner of a copyright has the exclusive right to reproduce and distribute copies of the copyrighted work, and to prepare derivative works (adaptations, translations, etc.) based on the copyrighted work. If the work can be performed, such as a musical or dramatic work, the copyright owner has the exclusive right to perform it publicly. In the case of a work that can be displayed, such as a picture, sculpture or motion picture, the copyright owner may prevent others from displaying the work without the owner's permission. All of these rights are subject to the doctrine of "fair use," which permits limited use of copyrighted works for certain beneficial purposes (for example, teaching and research) without the permission of the copyright owner.
Like a patent, a copyright is considered to be property, and may therefore be sold and licensed. Claims to copyright may be registered in the Copyright Office, a branch of the Library of Congress, located in Washington, D.C. When a copyrighted work is published, well-advised copyright owners place a notice of copyright on the copies of the work as a warning to would-be copiers. Such notice may consist of a "c" enclosed by a circle, the date (at least the year) and the name of the copyright owner.
From 19th-century photographs to 20th-century computer programs, U.S. copyright law has protected artists and authors in numerous ways. For example:
In 1882 an enterprising New York photographer carefully posed the famous Irish dramatist and poet, Oscar Wilde, and took a remarkable photograph showing him in a deeply pensive mood. Soon afterwards, without the photographer's permission, a lithographer produced 85,000 copies of the photo and began selling them. The photographer sued for copyright infringement and was awarded damages. Copyright law protected the fruits of the photographer's creative efforts.
The popular Lotus 1-2-3 computer spreadsheet employs a visible menu command system that has a unique structure, sequence and organization. When a rival company copied this element of the program, a court held that the element was protected by the Lotus copyright, and the would-be copier was forced to devise its own menu.
A trademark is a word, a group of words or a logo that is used in connection with the sale of goods to distinguish them from those made or sold by someone else. Words and logos are also used in the sale of services, such as those offered by insurance companies, hockey teams and rock groups; such marks are called service marks.
By using a trademark or service mark in the sale of goods or services, the owner of a mark acquires the right to exclude others from using a similar mark on other products in a way that is likely to confuse the purchasing public. This is a valuable right to a business entity, because of the time and effort invested in building public goodwill in a product and the mark. Trademark protection also protects the public against the consequences of confusion, buying something which they believe to be one thing when in fact it is something else.
An example of a trademark infringement case in the past is:
Geoffrey Inc. v. Stratton, 16 U.S.P.Q. 2d 1691 (D.C.Cal.1990) Plaintiff Geoffrey, the owner of TOYS-R-US® and KIDS-R-US® stores, sued Stratton for trademark infringement as a result of the operation of its PHONES-R-US store. Since 1960, Geoffrey had used marks containing the "R-US" suffix for children's toys, furniture and other goods. Stratton, the "junior" user of the "R-US" suffix, sold retail telephone sales and services. Finding infringement, the court explained that even without registration of the "R-US" suffix per se , that suffix was exclusively associated with Geoffrey by virtue of its family of "R-US" marks. Because the court found that the PHONES-R-US mark was designed to confuse the public and trade upon Geoffrey's goodwill, Stratton was found liable.
Trademark protection is recognized under the laws of individual states and is enforceable in state courts. Marks may be registered with state administrative agencies, usually the Secretary of State.
There is also a federal Trademark Act that provides for registration of marks used or intended for use in interstate commerce. Important advantages flow from federal registration. For example, registration is constructive notice throughout the U.S. that the registrant claims ownership. And, after five years of continuous use, no one may contest the registrant's right to continue to use the mark. Also, federal registration allows the registrant access to the federal court system in infringement suits.
Such well-known trademarks and service marks as Coca-Cola®, Kodak®, Buick®, Kellogg's®, Burger King®, Reynolds Wrap®, Jell-O®, Xerox®, Motorola®, AT&T®, Michelob®, Exxon®, Polaroid®, Visa® and Sanka® are widely recognized by consumers as reliable signals that a product or service offered for sale originates from the same source year after year, and that the quality of the product or service will not vary. Business competitors invest millions of dollars in advertising to publicize the goodwill that marks represent. Consumers identify such marked goods as having particular characteristics and merit. In our market economy, trademarks play a critical role in the language of advertising. Competition would indeed be cumbersome and impractical without them.
Business competitors are sometimes victims of industrial espionage that takes the form of theft of business ideas and methods. Trade secret protection is a sturdy shield against such tactics.
A trade secret is an idea or information that has commercial value because it is not widely known. "Trade secret" is a broad concept that includes a wide variety of business methods, processes, machines, formulas, patterns and techniques that are kept secret from one's business competitors.
Trade secret protection is acquired as soon as the idea or information is created, and lasts for as long as the information is protected as, and remains, a secret, under applicable statutory provisions. Trade secrets are protected primarily by the laws of the several states. Protection is available against anyone who steals the secret or uses it without permission. Many states have criminal statutes outlawing theft of trade secrets.
Although trade secret protection is potentially perpetual, it does not prevent someone else from discovering the information independently by proper means, such as "reverse engineering" of a product that has been sold on the open market. However, applicable copyright or patent laws may preempt use of a reverse engineering discovery.
Kevin Culligan Helps to Expand the Intellectual Property Practice at King & Spalding, LLP