The best news controversy of the week, for my money, is the alleged falling out between Scalia and Alito. During Alito's Senate confirmation hearing, it was predicted that Alito would be Baby Scalia, following in the arch conservative jurist's footsteps. But it seems a rift has emerged. The media has made a bigger deal out of it than need be, most likely. But in an age when Jessica Simpson vs. Lindsay Lohan and Nicole Richie vs. Paris Hilton pass as celebrity feuds, it's nice to see one of substance. Earlier this week, Alito wrote the court's unanimous opinion in Zedner v. United States, which involved a dispute regarding the Speedy Trial Act. Alito cited legislative history, much to Scalia's chagrin. Scalia had spoken out against interpreting Congressional acts in decisions previously, and he rebuked Alito for it in his concurrence. Underneath Their Robes is calling it a judicial bitch slap.
"Because the use of legislative history is illegitimate and ill advised in the interpretation of any statute—and especially a statute that is clear on its face—I do not join this portion of the Court's opinion."
Alito had the chance to appease Scalia by removing the offending paragraph, but opted not to do so. Orrin Kerr stated that this is evidence that Alito will not wind up being the conservative extremist many predicted him to be. At the very least, don't call him Scalito.
Marty Schwimmer of the Trademark Blog was tapped by Blawg Review to write this week's summary of notable law blog activity. While the weekly Blawg Review is usually a list of links, he chose to instead author a scathing indictment of the illegality of American domestic and international activities. Schwimmer touches on everything: Guantanamo Bay, Bush's State of the Union announcement that Saddam had attempted to buy yellow cake enriched uranium from Niger, the NSA wiretaps, the Valerie Plame leak, torture in Iraq, etc. In the end, we're not left with any answers, just more questions.
Finally, on Evan Schaeffer's Legal Underground, Schaeffer recently authored a blog post about his new career as an Internet sensation. He reports to be enjoying the spoils of being a famous blogger. Over the past year or so, the Legal Underground blog has become one of the more frequently cross-linked blogs. As a celebrity Internet attorney, Schaeffer enjoys rock star status, including being recognized at the DMV, earning frequent compliments from judges and opposing attorneys, and receiving scorn from his rival bloggers. He is the latest attorney with a blog to make it as a cult celeb, but probably not the last.
So think of Inside Law Blogs as Access Hollywood without Arthel Neville. We'll be right back in two minutes and two seconds.
