Most Law & Legal Jobs on Earth - LawCrossing

Login

Try It Now!

Share


EMPLOYERS, POST LEGAL JOBS | SEARCH RESUMES

ATTORNEYS LAW STUDENTS LEGAL STAFF
Feature
 
Guilty until proven innocent

By Frank Lee

Better a guilty man remain free than an innocent man be imprisoned. That is the bedrock of the American judicial system. But a closer look would show the foundation of jurisprudence is not as incontrovertible as we would like to believe.

Recent Articles
BigLaw Attorneys' Folly with Mail Gets Death Row Inmate New Hearing
What Attorneys Can Learn From Steve Jobs
Aristotle Technology Eases Compliance with Regulations Regarding Political Contributions
Veteran Attorney Takes Radio Gig
Passing the Sniff Test
+ Archives
Guilty until proven innocent
Guilty until proven innocent
+ Enlarge
The American judicial system shows the foundation of jurisprudence which is not as incontrovertible as we would like to believe.
Brandon Moon, a former University of Texas at El Paso student, had served nearly 17 years of a 75-year sentence after his 1988 conviction on three counts of sexual assault before he was freed when DNA evidence eventually exonerated him of the crimes.

The 43-year-old's rape conviction was taken up this fall by the attorneys and law students at the New York-based Innocence Project, which handles only cases in which DNA evidence can be used to prove the innocence of a convicted person.

The Innocence Project at the Benjamin N. Cardozo School of Law at Yeshiva University is a nonprofit, donor-funded legal clinic and criminal justice resource center that works to exonerate the wrongfully convicted through post-conviction DNA testing. "We take cases where DNA—biological evidence—is the determinant of innocence or guilt in a case," said Maddy deLone, executive director of the Innocence Project and a prisoners' rights attorney who has worked in the correctional facility system for nearly two decades. "Those cases are largely sexual assaults, rape cases, and sometimes murder cases."

The Innocence Project at the Cardozo School of Law was created by Barry C. Scheck and Peter J. Neufeld in 1992. Mr. Scheck was one of the high-profile attorneys on O.J. Simpson's so-called "dream team" of defense lawyers at his 1995 criminal trial.

"We receive thousands of requests every year for help, and there are also about 40 other 'projects' (like ours) around the country that take appeals for assistance for people: post-conviction innocence appeals," Ms. deLone said. For example, the Chicago-based Center on Wrongful Convictions at Northwestern University School of Law is another group that is dedicated to identifying and rectifying wrongful convictions and other miscarriages of justice.

"Projects that don't do DNA cases, in general, tend to spend a lot more time talking to a person about his innocence and trying to make a decision whether they really believe he is innocent," Ms. deLone said. "We don't spend an enormous amount of time trying to vet the veracity of someone's claims of innocence. We let the biology do that," explained Ms. deLone.

Under the supervision of co-directors Mr. Scheck and Mr. Neufeld, three full-time attorneys, 21 law students from the Cardozo School of Law, and law students from law schools around the country work on behalf of those they represent.

"When we find a case where a lab technician or forensic scientist testifies falsely either purposefully or through negligence, we call for audits of that person's work to ensure that there haven't been other criminal defendants similarly wrongly convicted," Ms. deLone said.

"In the DNA world alone, there have been 154 exonerations across the country of people who were serving, in general, lengthy sentences: 14 of those people on death row and others often 25 years and up for crimes they didn't commit." People just like Mr. Moon, who throughout his incarceration maintained his innocence, even when a serologist testified that Mr. Moon was among the 15 percent of the population who could have been the source of semen evidence presented at trial.

"There are no uniform laws of evidence preservation across this country, so every jurisdiction has its own rules. Right now, it can differ even between adjoining counties," Ms. deLone said.

Nina Morrison, an attorney with the Innocence Project, has said Mr. Moon would be released on $1 bond until his conviction is officially vacated by the state Court of Criminal Appeals in Texas. "In our most recent exoneration in Texas, we filed the statement of facts jointly with the district attorney in El Paso, who saw that the conviction was wrongful…and that his office participated in the conviction," Ms. deLone said.

Indeed, Ms. deLone noted that the Project often works with local courts to see justice served. "We do have many friends in law enforcement, because we try to undo wrongs, and most people are supportive of that. And in the course of exonerating these people, we often find the real criminals in some of these horrific cases."

Still, cases like Mr. Moon's represent a "horror of horrors" for a society striving to be just and may operate, in some cases, to undermine confidence in the justice system by others. "I think it's hard for people to believe that there are wrongfully convicted people. It certainly is a difficult thing for a prosecuting agency to come to grips with, although some of them have done that admirably…while others resist beyond reason," Ms. deLone said.

She observed, "It's easier to live in a world where you think everything works the way it's supposed to work. And I think these exoneration cases tell us it doesn't and also point to times where there are problems where we could improve the justice system."

The federal "Justice for All" Act of 2004 increases the maximum amount of damages that the U.S. Court of Federal Claims may award in cases of unjust imprisonment, from $5,000 to $50,000 per year in non-capital cases, and $100,000 per year in capital cases.

"I think you can never completely make up for depriving somebody of their liberty for what is often more than 10, sometimes more than 20, years, but some states and the federal government have compensation laws," Ms. deLone said.

According to the Innocence Project, "DNA testing…is not a panacea for the ails of the criminal justice system," so the Innocence Project is also active in the effort to pass new laws and implement new policies in order to reverse and prevent wrongful convictions.

"We say 'beyond a reasonable doubt,' so we have a reluctance, as a society, to put innocent people in prison…or so the story goes," Ms. deLone said. "But it's hard to imagine a judicial system which would absolutely be 'error free.'"

Nonetheless, with groups like the Innocence Project elucidating ways to improve the system, hopefully our error rate will go down and we will have fewer who are guilty until proven innocent.

Printable Version    Printable Version PDF Version    PDF Version Email to a Friend    Email to a Friend
Comment    Post A Comment View Comment    View Comment Discuss    Discuss
Popular Tags
 O.J. Simpson  correctional institution  Yeshiva University  attorneys  death row  DNA  Cardozo School of Law  Court of Federal Claims  non-profit organizations  rape

Featured Testimonials

I just sort of stumbled upon LawCrossing. I'm glad I did because it's an awesome service!
Martin F.

Facts

LawCrossing Fact #17: The “FAQ” section lists a large variety of commonly asked questions that LawCrossing users might have along with helpful answers.

"We want to hear your thoughts. Please comment on this article (below)!"

Comments


Article ID: 663    

Article Title: Guilty until proven innocent

Comment not found for this article.

Comment Comment

Facebook comments:

Rate This Article
   View top rated articles
Related Article
Sign Up Now

Enjoyed reading this article?
Click here to sign up for News Wire, our weekly newsletter, and you'll receive articles just like this right in your inbox.

Jd Journal - Send Tips
JDJournal

Enter your email address and start getting breaking law firm and legal news right now!



Every Alert

Alert once a day

 

Total Legal Jobs
150,396
Upload Your Resume
New Legal Jobs in Last 7 Days
21,941
LEGAL JOB SEARCH

Job Type:



Browse Jobs by Location:



Employer Type:



Keyword Search:



Show Recruiter Jobs  What's this?
Show Refreshed Jobs  What's this?


+ Advanced Search    + Browse Jobs

+ Search Tips
Get your risk FREE trial
SIGN UP NOW
*Email:  
Only LawCrossing consolidates every job it can find in the legal industry and puts all of the job listings it locates in one place.

  • We have more than 25 times as many legal jobs as any other job board.
  • We list jobs you will not find elsewhere that are hidden in small regional publications and employer websites.
  • We collect jobs from more than 250,000 websites and post them on our site.
  • Employers can post jobs for free.
  • We are private, and therefore far fewer people are applying for the jobs on our site than are applying for those on public job boards.
BCG Attorney Jobs
LEGAL JOBS NEAR YOU

Map Search  What's this?

New search feature using US map.  + click here

Looking for a new legal job in your city?
+ click here

Where do you want to work?  + click here
  CAREER CONNECT  (From Our Career Blogs)
WHAT MEMBERS ARE SAYING

Megan

I found the site to be very useful. For attorney jobs, I have not found any other site with nearly as many listings.

Jennifer

I found LawCrossing to be very easy to use and helpful in my job search. Thanks.

+ More success stories
+ Share your success story with us
USEFUL LINKS

  US News Law School Rankings 2011

  Lateral Attorney Report
   The Recruiters of BCG Attorney Search


  Legal Job Market: Facts and Figures

  Add LawCrossing to My Favorites
What is LawCrossing?
Who Else Is Ready to Never Have to Worry About Recessions and the Legal Job Market Again?
Why Job Boards Are Evil!
Blow Away Your Competition with LawCrossing
Get More Employers to Respond to Your Applications and Hire You
Why You Are Not Aware of 95% of the Jobs Out There
Why LawCrossing's Marketing Problem is Good For You
Why It is Important to See Every Job Site There is
Private Versus Public Job Boards
Why You Need to Manage Your Job Search in One Place
Who Else Wants Their Phone Ringing Off the Hook With Quality Job Interviews?
Do Not Use Another Job Board Until You Read This
Facebook Twitter
Top 101 Reasons to Sign Up for LawCrossing
Reason 24: Your competitors will find job openings online or in newspapers only if the employers have actively advertised. LawCrossing tells you about job openings whether employers want us to or not.
  Click here for 100 more reasons  
BCG Attorney Search
Real-Time Job Updates
Sign up free and receive new jobs by email as soon as they become available.

First Name


Email


Areas of Practice


Regions of Interest


Free Report

The Five "Big Dirty Secrets" of Job Sites

Just enter your email to get the Report
The Five ''Big Dirty Secrets'' of Job Sites
Download Your Free E-Book
Today at LawCrossing

1,876 - Jobs found in last 12 hours 2,080 - Jobs found in last 24 hours 150,396 - Total Jobs Found
I Love LawCrossing
Your privacy is guaranteed. We will never give out, lease, or sell your personal information. Whitelist LawCrossing

Job Seekers - Job Search
Sign Up  |  LawCrossing Benefits  |  Testimonials  |  Create Resume  |  Job Search Advice  |  Attorney Jobs  |  Law Student Jobs  |  Legal Staff Jobs  |  Legal Jobs  |  Browse Jobs  |  Search Jobs by Location  |  Search Jobs by Type  |  Advanced Job Search  |  Set Job Alerts  |  Five Big Secrets of Job Sites

Job Seekers - Resources
Career Advice Articles  |  Resume Writing Service  |  Post Resume  |  Send Resume  |  Resume Distribution  |  Career Advice  |  Job Search Tips  |  Legal Career Feature  |  Legal Daily News Feature  |  Life Style  |  Law Job Star  |  Law Firm News  |  Career Counsel  |  Law School Profile  |  Court Reporter  |  Career Corner  |  Inside Legal Blogs  |  Personal Finance  |  Law Student Profile  |  Invite A Friend

General Resources
Employers / Recruiters - Post Jobs  |  About Us  |  History  |  Our Mission  |  Core Values  |  Terms of Use  |  Privacy Policy  |  The LawCrossing Guarantee  |  Our Promise  |  Site Map  |  How We Help You  |  What We'll Never Do  |  Why You Need Us  |  Why We're Not Free  |  Career   |  Press Room  |  Audio Room  |  Videos  |  Law Firm News  |  Legal Recruiter  |  Advertise with Us

Our Partner Sites:
LawCrossing  |  BCG Attorney Search
Employment Research Institute  VeriSign Secure Site  Privacy Policy by TRUSTe