Freedom v. Intolerance

10 Views
05/14/10

For the second time in a year, a cross posted on public lands as a historic marker has been stolen. In both cases, the cross was the subject of legal action under the first amendment.



In September of last year, vandals cut down a cross on public beach in Monterey, California. The Monterey cross was erected in 1969 as part of the city's bicentennial celebration. It marked the spot where Don Gaspar de Portola erected a wooden cross in 1769 as a beacon to a resupply ship from Mexico that was lost at sea. The city claimed that it was an historical monument and not a religious display. Prior to the theft of the cross by vandals, the ACLU had been challenging the monument on the grounds that it violated the establishment clause of the first amendment. Last month the cross was restored, but on private land instead of on the public beach.

I was reminded of the Monterey Cross today as I read stories about the Mojave Cross. For those not familiar with the story thus far, the Mojave Cross was erected in 1934 by WW I veterans as a memorial for fallen comrades. It was built on a rock in a relatively remote part of the Mojave Desert, part of the Mojave National Preserve. After a parks employee sued on the grounds that it violated the establishment clause of the first amendment, Congress tried to sidestep the issue by selling a small piece of land including the rock on which the cross stood to the VFW. The 9th Circuit issued an injunction barring the sale from taking effect and the case headed to the Supreme Court where it was decided less than two weeks ago. In a divided opinion in which 6 justices wrote opinions, the Court voted 5-4 to remand the case back to the district court saying that the court should consider the law an accommodation, not an evasion, and to consider other alternatives such as posting a sign that identifies the land as private property.

Setting aside the legal debate about the establishment clause and the extent to which it prohibits the display of religious symbols on public property, these two stories raise an even higher issue. A free society that allows for different, sometimes conflicting, religions to co-exist cannot endure in the face of religious intolerance. Freedom isn't free – it comes with responsibility. In this case, the price of religious freedom is tolerance, tolerance to those whose beliefs differ from our own. Those who would seek to destroy the symbols of a religion different from their own do themselves a disservice, for the destruction of any religious expression threatens their own freedom to worship, or not to worship, as they choose. Whether the vandals were members of another religious group or atheists, intolerance threatens their own religious freedom as well.




Featured Testimonials

LawCrossing is perfect in its timely updations. Plus, I like its everyday email updates.
Robert


Facts

LawCrossing Fact #41: All LawCrossing users get 20% off resume-writing services from Resume Apple, a company that specializes in a variety of industries.


Location
New York City, NY
Description
Associate Court Attorney (Trial Part) Duties: Research and analyze complex and difficult legal issu...
Apply now  
Location
New York City, NY
Description
Senior Court Attorney (Trial Part) JG - 25 Duties: Work with substantial independence from supervis...
Apply now  
Location
New York City, NY
Description
Court Attorney (Trial Part) Duties: Research and analyze legal issues and questions and perform oth...
Apply now  
Location
New York City, NY
Description
Staff Attorney The candidate will assist in agency’s Supreme Court litigation, including merits b...
Apply now  
Location
Charleston, WV
Description
Appellate Litigator The candidate will be briefing and arguing appeals before the Supreme Court of ...
Apply now  
Location
Indianapolis, IN
Description
Attorney I The candidate will be responsible for providing effective representation of counsel to i...
Apply now  
 

NOW TRENDING ON BCG ATTORNEY SEARCH

MOST POPULAR ARTICLES

Testimonial of the Week

LawCrossing is great at picking up all of the legal listings everywhere across the internet. I could have gone to three different sites to search, but you had them all on your site. That was extremely helpful. LawCrossing is a one stop shop!
  • Eileen Baca-Penner New Mexico
Job of the Day

Construction Litigation Associate

San Antonio, TX

Our client is a boutique construction law firm headquartered in San Antonio, Texas.  The firm handles transactional and...

Employer: Preferred Counsel Legal Placement

Job Search Tip

Dress to impress. Invest in an interview wardrobe. You'll need more than one outfit since you'll interview more than once at any given company.