|Some think the way female attorneys tend to be portrayed on television is still a far cry from reality.|
From Ally McBeal to Shirley Schmidt, some of the most popular characters in TV Land have been female attorneys; but have their on-screen portrayals been accurate? Stephanie Goldberg thinks so. In an article in the fall 2005 issue of Perspectives magazine, Goldberg credited attorneys-turned-writers, such as Jill Goldsmith, with ensuring this accuracy.
Goldsmith, who graduated from Washington University School of Law, practiced law for seven years before heading for Hollywood, where she became a writer for both The Practice and Law and Order. Goldsmith began writing for The Practice after the characters were created. She said the female characters were formed in the same way and along the same lines as the male characters.
"All of the characters were a blend of aggressive courtroom presence and emotional vulnerability," she told Perspectives.
Rikki Klieman, Court TV anchor and author of Fairy Tales Can Come True, said she sees characters such as Shirley Schmidt, Helen Gamble, Abby Carmichael, and Grace Van Owen as great role models.
"They're good strategists, they're highly competent, and they're always prepared," she said in Perspectives. "They're passionate about justice, and they have a range of emotions."
While some female attorneys on television have been portrayed as fashion-conscious women in miniskirts and high heels (Ally McBeal), other portrayals have been more realistic. For example, many feel that The Practice's Eleanor Frutt, who was played by Camryn Mannheim, was a breath of fresh air in the often unrealistic world of television drama. Mannheim's plus-sized character had many fans, one of whom was Star Jones Reynolds from The View. Reynolds, who is an attorney herself, has been quoted as saying that she appreciates seeing women of varying "shapes, sizes, and races" playing active parts in the legal field.
However, some think the way female attorneys tend to be portrayed on television is still a far cry from reality. For example, while most female attorneys on television are single, live in nice condos, have no children, work in criminal law, and do not have large extended families, many female attorneys in the real world do manage to have husbands, children, and families. They also practice in a broader range of areas.
A good example of a character many female lawyers in the real world would find unrealistic is Sex and the City's Miranda Hobbes, played by Cynthia Nixon. Hobbes is the epitome of the ultra-driven career woman. By working hard and dedicating herself to her career, Hobbes made partner in her firm, an accomplishment she was extremely proud of. However, in her personal life, she was habitually closed-off, tough, and even cold at times. Feeding the stereotype of female lawyers as hard-hearted, career-driven women, Nixon's character even expressed the fear that she didn't have a maternal instinct when she was faced with an unexpected pregnancy.
A more realistic character is Judging Amy's Amy Gray, played by Amy Brenneman. Brenneman's character, who is a judge, is a divorced mother who is doing her best to raise her daughter and handle a career. Focusing on real issues that most working mothers face, Judging Amy does a good job of representing professional females in today's workforce as they are.
With the role of women in the professional world evolving every day, working as a female attorney can be both challenging and encouraging. Over the years, there seems to have been a trend toward more accurate portrayals of female lawyers; and with the current trend in television leaning toward "reality," that portrayal should only become more accurate.
LawCrossing is a pretty well managed website. It is the easiest site to navigate. Thanks!
LawCrossing Fact #131: Our researchers don’t post jobs indiscriminately just to meet a quota. They and the jobs they find are carefully screened.